Monday, April 4, 2011

A Psychological Analysis of Sports

This pertains to professional and national-level sports teams, not your neighborhood pick up basketball. I should also note that i'm not building this on top of any previous knowledge, im just describing things that ive noticed personally.

I've always wondered why people care about professional sports like the NBA, NFL, MLB, etc. Similarly, i've always wondered why people care which celebrity is dating whom, who is feuding with whom, etc. I dont recall exactly where, but i do remember reading that people tend to be very interested in other people's lives when they have nothing of important going on in their own. The person who gives you constant advice on how they think you should deal with your interpersonal relationships is not likely to have any deep and meaningful relationships of their own. (It might have been Eric Hoffer's "The True Believer")

This can readily be applied to America's intense and ultimately stupid fixation with celebrities, which tends to be the case with females more then men. Women who lack meaningful relationships will buy People magazine and live out the relations they wish they had through the beautiful and young celebrities. This is the best explanation i have for why people give a damn how much weight so-and-so lost, or who broke up with whom.

The previous paragraph tends to deal mostly with women, who i think psychologically have a greater dependency on close interpersonal relationships then men. Thats a very broad generalization to make, i know, but i still think it holds true for the most part. In analyzing sports, I argue that men fulfill their inherent masculine psychological needs by living them through professional sports teams. Men have a tendency towards competing with one another for dominance either through war or sport. Themselves lacking any sport to be world champion of or battle to slay their enemies in, the average male projects his masculine psychological tendencies or needs into the professional sports team of his choice as if he were on the team. Thus he feels achievement when his favorite team wins a championship and dejection when they lose, though he played no part in it whatsoever.

I should note that following professional sports teams closely/closely following the lives of celebrities is in no way gender exclusive, its just that the majority of people following one are female, while the majority of people following the other are male.

Sports are also a way for social groups to peacefully compete with one another. Whereas in past eras they may have gone to war, boston and new york now meet each other in baseball games. This property of sport is best exhibited on the national level, where national sports teams are the projection of the national itself in competition with another nation. Tournaments like the olympics, the world cup, etc. are all ways for nations to compete for dominance with each other. In such tournaments, the team each nation fields is a representation in microcosm of the nation itself. Hence, it truly is a matter of national pride how each team performs against a rival nation (miracle on ice, anyone?). Hence, we feel each win and loss of our national teams as if we were somehow involved ourselves. Hence students deeply care about how their college or high school team performs in the football game against it's rival, although the competition really means nothing in terms of which school is better. Its more of a symbolic battle being carried out between the two.

I should also add that some people will argue that professional sports teams represent the city/area. That still doesnt invalidate my claim however, as many people cheer for teams whose cities theyve never been to, and the teams themselves dont represent anything. The government of a city does not sponsor a professional team, nor look through it's citizens for it's athletes. Professional athletes as well as their franchises are mercenaries; they hold no allegiance to their area. Associating the two together was merely a clever marketing ploy by those in charge of the franchise, so that people will believe that they are together when theyre not.

8 comments:

  1. you have a lot of time on your hands amigo but these are very amusing

    ReplyDelete
  2. good, because amusing was certainly what i was aiming for.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Not criticisms, just extended thoughts i'd be interested to see your reaction to:

    the green bay packers are publically owned by its citizens, nearly every area's citizens pay tax dollars that go towards new stadiums, marketing campaigns, etc.

    how do you react to the thought of rooting for a professional team of which one personally knows a player on the roster?

    why do we root for people individuals in sports? why do i choose between lebron and kobe when i have no relation to either (geographic, collegiate, personal, etc)?

    perhaps we pay attention to sports not because theyre inconsequential ways to release psychological angst but because they are, every once in a blue moon, more consequential than almost anything else in our society and we yearn for that 1 in 1000 moment where you can see the best of human nature exhibited on the playing field and translated to society on the whole, i.e. carl lewis' black glove on the olympic podium, derek redmond's dad running with him in the '92 olympics after he tore his hamstring, new york yankees first game played after the 9/11 attacks, jesse owens impressing hitler, jimmy valvanos speech at the 1993 ESPY awards, or jason mcelwain's spirit in a mere high school basketball game (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1fw1CcxCUgg)... perhaps these moments are recognized as times when we, as humans, learn something about ourselves that requires a level of introspection that rarely comes on its own and for that reason we desire to see, through the nature of sportsmanship, moments that enable such introspection.

    again, just a thought (in run on sentence form)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well in terms of the green bay packers, it's difficult to say exactly because i dont know exactly what their financial situation is. However i really think that public tax dollars shouldnt be going to private organizations like the NFL. Also it could be that tax dollars go towards creating the stadiums themselves, which the NFL uses for its games. Again i dont really know the financial situation. Nevertheless, professional teams still are not projections of their area even if they are partially funded by them. Their athletes are not exclusively from that area, and franchises change locations all the time.

    Rooting for a team upon which you know a player wouldn't fall under the categories of what i was discussing earlier.

    Rooting for individuals like choosing between lebron/kobe would fall more under the category of psychological projecting oneself into a celebrity. It doesnt matter so much as why you chose between them so much as the fact that you chose between them. As a non world-class basketball player, you tend to try to closely follow them as one would a celebrity in a gossip magazine. Same concept with slightly different variation.

    I'm not 100% sure what your last paragraph is talking about, so ill paraphrase and please correct me if im wrong. Youre saying that people follow sports because of great and emotional moments that occur in them, which enables introspection.

    Well, you assertion may well be true, but i doubt that people learn different players statistics, debate which players will be drafted by whom, and whom deserves which award in an attempt to see the best of human nature in them. Certainly some sports stories are highly symbolic and emotional in nature, but i dont think that really explains why so many people care so much about teams who care so little about them. Id explain these moments more as stories that we become enamored to. The fact that they involve sports i think has little to do with our obsession. Its more of an emotional story that we are fixated on that happens to involve sports, and not the other way around. Also, im curious as to how the moments you listed led to personal introspection and what came from that introspection.

    Also, id like to remind people reading this that im not arguing loving professional sports is a bad thing, im just purporting a reason why a phenomenon happens.

    ReplyDelete
  5. well played sir well played

    ReplyDelete
  6. haha thanks, assuming you meant me

    ReplyDelete
  7. Dave! You are a very astute young man and in my humble opinion hit the nail right square on the head! I have often wondered the same thing about people and couldn't agree with you more. Keep up the good work!

    Coach Jordan

    ReplyDelete